When it comes to crocheting amigurumi, the yarn you choose makes a big difference. It affects the final look, the texture, and even how enjoyable the process is. Over the years of designing crochet patterns and making dozens of toys, I’ve tested many types of yarn — and I’m excited to share what works best and why.
🧶 My Go-To: Cotton-Acrylic Blend (Sport Weight)
For most of my toys, I use a soft, smooth blend of cotton and acrylic — typically 55% cotton and 45% acrylic — in sport weight (2). It’s perfect for the kind of toys I love to make: small, detailed, and neat.
This type of yarn gives great stitch definition, which helps with tiny features like facial expressions, clothing elements, or accessories. It doesn’t split easily and has just the right amount of stretch, making it comfortable to work with.
If you love making miniatures or characters with sharp detail, I truly recommend giving it a try.
Want to see how this yarn works up in real projects?
Take a look at my Diva Plavalaguna Pattern, The Grinch Pattern, or Harry Potter & Sorting Hat Bundle Pattern. All are designed with this exact yarn blend in mind.
🐻 For Cozy and Huggable: Plush Yarn
Sometimes, I switch to plush yarn — usually a super bulky (6) velvet or chenille-type yarn — when I want the toy to be more cuddly and soft. This kind of yarn is perfect for cute, squeezable creatures. It works up quickly and creates a luxurious, velvety texture that feels wonderful to the touch.
However, keep in mind: the stitches are harder to see, which makes this yarn less suitable for tiny pieces or intricate details. I typically use a larger hook and simpler shapes to keep things enjoyable and stress-free.
Want something quick and beginner-friendly?
Try my Furby-Inspired Pattern! It’s made with plush yarn, works up fast, and is perfect for beginners.
👽 For Texture and Impact: Fluffy Yarn
There’s also fluffy novelty yarn — like eyelash or furry yarn. It can be tricky to work with, especially for beginners, because the stitches are almost invisible. But the result can be absolutely stunning.
This yarn gives your toy a unique personality and texture. It’s best to start with small practice pieces and stick to basic shapes. I love using it for wild hair, monsters, or magical creatures.
Want to experiment?
Use the ALF Pattern to compare fluffy vs. cotton. I made one of each and they look like completely different toys!
✨ Final Thoughts
There’s no one “perfect yarn” for everyone. It all depends on your project and your style. If you’re into tiny, expressive toys like I am, a smooth cotton-acrylic blend in sport weight is ideal. If you’re going for soft and squishy, plush yarn is your best friend. And if you’re ready for a fun challenge, fluffy yarn might just surprise you with its magic.
Want to try different styles? Check out my crochet patterns here — and see how each yarn brings the toy to life!